Drag and Drop scoring error

The score for my Drag and Drop game was correct (out of 7) but then changed to 8 without me knowing. I cannot find what is responsible for the 8th point. I only have 7 elements and have made sure that each element only matches to one drop zone. Any help would be greatly appreciated.

BV52's picture

Hi Noni,

Would you mind sharing the content here so that we can check?

-BV52

Thank you. Is this the link you need: https://h5p.org/node/474129 

Noni

Thank you. Is this the link you need? https://h5p.org/node/474129

Noni

BV52's picture

Hi Noni,

Thank you for this. It is possible that this issue is related to this bug report. There could be a static text that you added initially and was a draggable but changed afterwards. My best bet for this is manually removing each and every text and re-adding them. I know it's a bit cumbersome but we have not come up with a fix for this bug.

-BV52

I experience very erratic behaviour for drag and drops in terms of score. At some point it goes beyond the editors control, something is being autogenerated.

BV52's picture

Hi knutinge,

Please elaborate on your issue. Does it have more points than it should have? Points are not given? A sample content may also help.

-BV

Tamara Webster's picture

Hello,

I am also having issues with drag and drop scoring. This activity should be out of 15 but is displaying out of 16.
https://icatcare.h5p.com/content/1291346879940156527
I have attached a screenshot to show the correct answers.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I have other examples of similar activities that show the score being much higher than the actual correct scoring, but these aren't ready to share yet.

Is there any way to manually set the total available points?

Thank you so much. 
Tamara

BV52's picture

Hi Tamara,

Would you mind attaching the content here. I can confirm the issue however Drag and Drop have one of the most complex scoring among content types and it is almost impossible to know what the issue is without looking at the settings.

-BV

Tamara Webster's picture

Hello BV, 

Thank you for your reply. How do I go about attaching the content here?
Our content is hosted on https://icatcare.h5p.com/

All the best
Tamara

BV52's picture

Hi Tamara,

You need to enable the download/reuse button. You can check this documentation for steps on how to do this. To attach the content there is an option to attach this when commnenting on the post.

-BV

otacke's picture
BV52's picture

I bet you're right ;-)

Tamara Webster's picture

Hi BV and otacke,

Thank you for letting me know how to attach the file, I have done so. 

I will have a look through the links provided regarding the HFP-2444 issue, thank you. 

Tamara


 
otacke's picture

Hi Tamara!

Those links will probably not help you solve your issue: It's a known bug in H5P that technically has been fixed, but the H5P core team will have to find the time to review the code that I provided and to release an update with the fix in order to wipe out that bug

Best,
Oliver

Tamara Webster's picture

I see! Thank you for the quick reply and information. 

I am hoping to use this, and other activities of the same structure, in a course that is being launched in November. 
Do you think there is any chance that this update might be developed and applied before November?
There is one other activity in this series where the scoring doesn't function as needed. 

Thank you 
Tamara

 

BV52's picture

Hi Tamara,

I would suggest that you send an email through the contact form and I will make sure to send it to the developers of H5P.com.

To make it easier to explain I suggest that you include the links that Oliver provided and tell them that you are also having the same issue.

-BV

otacke's picture

Hi Tamara!

What BV said. I'm not part of the H5P team, so I can't help here.

Best,

Oliver 

Tamara Webster's picture

Thank you for all your help and suggestions. 

papi Jo's picture

I have downloaded and carefully examined Tamara's "Spotty Right Maxilla" H5P content and can conclude that it does not reveal a bug, but an oversight in the creation of the dropzones.

As can be seen on the attached screenshot, the dropzone labelled "107" is (probably wrongly) expecting the draggable element labelled "2". If the draggable element "2" is dragged there, then the max score is achieved:

Suggested fix: Remove Draggable element "Text:2" from the list of correct elements of Drop zone "Drop 107 Other"

BV52's picture

Good catch! Thank you for looking into this Papi Jo.

-BV

Tamara Webster's picture

Thank you so much for taking the time to look through my activity and for spotting the error, I really appreciate it. 
I will carefully check through my other activity as I expect there is a similar issue there. 

Thank you!
Tamara